While orange roughy might sound exotic and appealing on a restaurant menu, you’re essentially eating a swimming toxic waste dump. These deep-sea fish can live up to 150 years, making them one of the longest-lived fish species on the planet.
Consider the environmental shifts over the past 150 years—industrial waste, nuclear fallout, chemical runoff, and numerous other pollutants have been steadily entering our oceans. Orange roughy, with their extremely long lifespans, have been exposed to all of it, gradually building up mercury, arsenic, cadmium, and lead in their bodies.
Because they inhabit deep ocean waters, orange roughy are also subjected to pollutants that sink and settle on the seafloor. Over time, these fish become reservoirs of environmental toxins, accumulating contaminant levels that can pose serious risks to human health.
The Surprising Toxin Absorber: Eel
Eel might not be an obvious choice for this list—especially given its popularity in sushi—but these snake-like fish are highly effective at soaking up environmental toxins.
What makes eels particularly worrisome is their ability to absorb a broad range of pollutants from their surroundings. It’s not just heavy metals—eels can also accumulate substances like fabric dyes, flame retardants, plasticizers, and various industrial chemicals. Their skin and fatty tissues act like sponges, concentrating these toxins to levels that can be hazardous to human health.
The concern grows even more because many eels are harvested from polluted waters near industrial zones. The rivers and estuaries they inhabit often collect runoff from factories, urban centers, and farms, exposing eels to a toxic mix of contaminants throughout their lifespans.
What makes tilefish especially troubling is how often it’s mislabeled. It’s sometimes sold under names like “golden snapper” or simply “snapper,” which can mislead consumers into thinking they’re choosing a safer fish when they’re not.
Better Choices for a Healthier Plate
Now that you know which fish to be cautious about, let’s focus on the ones that actually support your health. Wild-caught salmon is one of the best options, rich in omega-3 fatty acids and relatively low in contaminants.
Sardines and anchovies are also excellent picks. These small, short-lived fish don’t live long enough to accumulate high levels of toxins, and because they feed on plankton rather than other fish, they’re less likely to carry harmful substances.
If you’re in the mood for tuna, skipjack is a safer bet than larger species like albacore or bluefin. Thanks to its smaller size and shorter lifespan, skipjack contains fewer toxins, though it’s still wise to eat it in moderation.
Cod and trout, especially when sourced from cold, clean waters, are nutritious and carry minimal contamination risk. They’re a great way to get the benefits of omega-3s without the toxic burden found in larger predator fish.
Smarter Seafood Decisions
The secret to eating fish safely is understanding why certain choices are better. In general, smaller, faster-growing species from cleaner waters are much safer than large, long-lived predators from polluted areas.
When buying seafood, ask about the source. Wild-caught fish are typically healthier than farmed, and options from places like Alaska or the North Atlantic are often cleaner and more sustainable than fish from heavily industrialized regions.
The goal isn’t to stop eating fish—it’s to eat the right kinds. Fish can be an incredible source of lean protein and essential fats, but only if you choose wisely. With a little awareness and effort, you can enjoy all the health benefits of fish without exposing yourself to harmful toxins.
Your health deserves that extra bit of care. So next time you’re choosing seafood—whether at the market or in a restaurant—you’ll be equipped to make choices that truly support your well-being.
